Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

I'm trying to understand which options it's better ? Automatic Gain Control (-10)

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • I'm trying to understand which options it's better ? Automatic Gain Control (-10)

    or max Gain (+49.6) ?
    that is the result i'm getting on my graph.

    001c.jpg
    002c.jpg
    003c.jpg
    Last edited by ramimz; 2019-06-15, 07:49.

  • #2
    you excluded the most relevant graph: the first one, message rate.

    Both settings are probably fine.

    If you like looking at local close by low flying traffic, then 49.6 is most likely the better setting for you.
    With the higher gain some low flying close by traffic will disappear from the map.

    (maybe at 3 miles from your antenna)

    Comment


    • #3
      Hi..... sorry about that.
      here is the one with message rate.

      004c.jpg
      Attached Files
      Last edited by ramimz; 2019-06-15, 07:42.

      Comment


      • #4
        Compare two week days, that's a bit better than comparing like this.

        Also the graphs are an old version and don't display message >-3dB correctly.
        And you switched up the labels for -10 and 49.6 it seems.

        It's best to compare two complete weeks.

        Anyway these are my thoughts on gain:
        https://github.com/wiedehopf/adsb-wi...ptimizing-gain
        Last edited by wiedehopf; 2019-06-14, 17:25.

        Comment


        • #5
          First of all for ADS-B signals, the "gain -10" or "gain agc" does not set the gain to AGC. It sets gain to about 55 dB, which is higher than maximum value (49.6 dB) which can be set manually. This is due to very fluctuating nature of ADSB signal, while dongle is actually designed for receiving TV stations which have a stable signal level. In addition it is also due to a quirk in the RTL dongles.

          The value "gain max" sets gain to max designated value of 49.6

          Now the important question: What value is better?
          This depends entirely on location, hardware, and strength of interfering Cell/Mobile signals. It also depends on if you prefer to see long distance planes (highest gain setting) or close by / overhead planes (very low gain setting).

          For further reading:

          (1) Dump1090-mutability: About gain -10

          (2) ABOUT AGC

          (3) Do I need a Filter? - Find RF Signals In Area
          Last edited by abcd567; 2019-06-14, 18:15.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by wiedehopf View Post
            And you switched up the labels for -10 and 49.6 it seems.

            It's best to compare two complete weeks.

            Anyway these are my thoughts on gain:
            https://github.com/wiedehopf/adsb-wi...ptimizing-gain
            I fix it

            i will try it for longest time...... thanks

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by abcd567 View Post
              First of all for ADS-B signals, the "gain -10" or "gain agc" does not set the gain to AGC. It sets gain to about 55 dB, which is higher than maximum value (49.6 dB) which can be set manually. This is due to very fluctuating nature of ADSB signal, while dongle is actually designed for receiving TV stations which have a stable signal level. In addition it is also due to a quirk in the RTL dongles.

              The value "gain max" sets gain to max designated value of 49.6

              Now the important question: What value is better?
              This depends entirely on location, hardware, and strength of interfering Cell/Mobile signals. It also depends on if you prefer to see long distance planes (highest gain setting) or close by / overhead planes (very low gain setting).
              Thank you very much..... i have a lot of info to read on this weekend

              Comment

              Working...
              X